The image of a romantic noble robber is quite common in literature. Usually, these are people who, for whatever reason, become unnecessary in society. They are betrayed by friends and relatives, acquaintances turn away from them, and they cannot achieve anything legally, since the law is imperfect in such cases. Pushkin's story is about such a person, and after reading it, everyone begins to wonder why Dubrovsky became a robber?
Did Dubrovsky want such a share for himself?
The fate of a person can very often change depending on the circumstances. And, for sure, the young cornet did not suspect what would happen to him. He was brought up in the famous St. Petersburg Corps of Cadets, continued his military service and would have achieved a lot. If not for the occasion.
A misfortune occurs on his native estate: his old father quarrels with a friend and falls ill. Vladimir goes to him without a moment's hesitation. On the way, he learns about all the tragic events, and after the death of his father, he does an act worthy of a romantic hero: he burns down the estate and goes to the forest. He is surrounded by peasants who also do not like injustice and the power of money. Their devoted attitude towards Dubrovsky creates certain rules in the gang of robbers, to which everyone obeys.
All members of the gang understand their hopelessness and what awaits them in the future. Therefore, they rob and burn the estates, with each case toughening their actions. But the peasants do not touch Troekurov's Pokrovskoye estate: Masha lives there, who has become close and dear to Vladimir. He fell in love with her and refused revenge, but he is no longer able to stop the lawlessness of his comrades.
Reason for reincarnation
An officer with a bright future turns into a robber. Let fair, but the robber. And the reasons lie not only in himself. Yes, he is brave, decisive, even desperate. And around him is a rotten society. The noble robber Vladimir Dubrovsky lost all faith in law and justice. He begins to act with his own methods, but even in this case, he retains moral principles. His image of a robber is much purer and higher than these high-ranking officials and tyrants of landlords.
But, feeling sympathy for his hero, Pushkin reveals the real irony of such a reincarnation: having become a robber, Vladimir fell in love with the daughter of his enemy. He refused revenge. It turns out that all his actions committed earlier were in vain. You can try to explain his behavior, but you can’t justify his actions in any way. He broke the law, and no matter how hero Dubrovsky was for his peasants, he is a criminal. He committed murders, bringing events to a bloody massacre at the end of the story.
The image of a romantic noble robber is quite common in literature. Usually, these are people who, for whatever reason, become unnecessary in society. They are betrayed by friends and relatives, acquaintances turn away from them, and they cannot achieve anything legally, since the law is imperfect in such cases. Pushkin's story is about such a person, and after reading it, everyone begins to wonder why Dubrovsky became a robber?
Did Dubrovsky want such a share for himself?
The fate of a person can very often change depending on the circumstances. And, for sure, the young cornet did not suspect what would happen to him. He was brought up in the famous St. Petersburg Corps of Cadets, continued his military service and would have achieved a lot. If not for the occasion.
A misfortune occurs on his native estate: his old father quarrels with a friend and falls ill. Vladimir goes to him without a moment's hesitation. On the way, he learns about all the tragic events, and after the death of his father, he does an act worthy of a romantic hero: he burns down the estate and goes to the forest. He is surrounded by peasants who also do not like injustice and the power of money. Their devoted attitude towards Dubrovsky creates certain rules in the gang of robbers, to which everyone obeys.
All members of the gang understand their hopelessness and what awaits them in the future. Therefore, they rob and burn the estates, with each case toughening their actions. But the peasants do not touch Troekurov's Pokrovskoye estate: Masha lives there, who has become close and dear to Vladimir. He fell in love with her and refused revenge, but he is no longer able to stop the lawlessness of his comrades.
Reason for reincarnation
An officer with a bright future turns into a robber. Let fair, but the robber. And the reasons lie not only in himself. Yes, he is brave, decisive, even desperate. And around him is a rotten society. The noble robber Vladimir Dubrovsky lost all faith in law and justice. He begins to act with his own methods, but even in this case, he retains moral principles. His image of a robber is much purer and higher than these high-ranking officials and tyrants of landlords.
But, feeling sympathy for his hero, Pushkin reveals the real irony of such a reincarnation: having become a robber, Vladimir fell in love with the daughter of his enemy. He refused revenge. It turns out that all his actions committed earlier were in vain. You can try to explain his behavior, but you can’t justify his actions in any way. He broke the law, and no matter how hero Dubrovsky was for his peasants, he is a criminal. He committed murders, bringing events to a bloody massacre at the end of the story.
Cool! 17
Pushkin's novel "Dubrovsky" plunges us into the historical events taking place in the post-war years, the end of the Napoleonic invasion of Russia. The author of the work accurately describes the way of life, in the Russian villages of that time, of the common people and the fun of the landowners.
The work bears the name of its main character Dubrovsky. The plot of the novel is built on the story of a young landowner, his fate and worldview, which changes throughout the work. Vladimir Dubrovsky is a typical representative of the nobility. His life was measured and unhurried. The only heir to the estate, the future gentleman, after training in the cadet corps, served in the infantry regiment, in the glorious city of St. Petersburg, did not for a moment think about the hardships of the life of serfs. Dubrovsky led an uncomplicated lifestyle, did not bother himself with thoughts about the future and lost his father's money at cards, regularly sent to him in the required amount.
Like a bolt from the blue there was a letter announcing the illness of the protagonist's father. After this news, troubles fell on Vladimir one after another, this was the death of his father, whom the protagonist undoubtedly loved, and the loss of the estate, not without the help of the betrayal of Kirill Troekurov, his father's friend. This left an imprint on the future life of the young man. The events that took place forced Vladimir to look at life in a new way, he was no longer an irresponsible young man, but a man in whose hands was the fate of those under his command - the peasants.
The desire to take revenge, not only for himself, but also for the forced people, leads Dubrovsky to the robbery path. He becomes a robber, but a noble robber. Vladimir instills fear in people throughout the province. No one could feel at ease either in the villages or outside them. Having robbed the landowner's house, he simply burned it. The main character took away money, like the famous robber Robinhood, only from the rich, without resorting to murder.
But like many heroes of Pushkin A.S. the image of Vladimir is rather contradictory. Is it noble to be a robber, forcibly taking away property? Robbery and violence is a deadly sin. Could the main character have chosen a different path? He could serve in the army, earning a comfortable life. But Dubrovsky did not pay attention to all this and acted according to the dictates of his heart.
To implement the plan of revenge, the protagonist penetrates, like a teacher from France, into Troekurov's house. But the love boiling in Vladimir's heart for Masha calms his "thirst for blood." Dubrovsky no longer wants to take revenge on his sworn enemy.
The appearance of the "villain" for the first time the author describes in the house of Troekurov. Pushkin stops in detail, describing his features: medium height, brown eyes, blond hair, and twenty-three years of age. But the author paid more attention to the composure and courage of the protagonist, who was not afraid of a hungry bear.
Pushkin presented the hero of the novel as an adventurous knight, getting into non-standard situations and getting out of them in an unconventional way. As a romantic young man who uses the hollow of an oak tree as a mailbox to send notes to his beloved. This image makes the character unrealistic, but very interesting and unusual.
Even more essays on the topic: “Why Dubrovsky became a robber”:
Roman A.S. Pushkin "Dubrovsky" tells us about an honest, noble man, a young nobleman Vladimir Dubrovsky. Throughout the work, we see his life path, and the question inevitably arises: why did the officer of the Guards regiment suddenly become a robber?
Vladimir's father, Andrei Gavrilovich Dubrovsky, stupidly quarreled with his neighbor Kirila Petrovich Troekurov. Both friends loved to hunt. But Andrei Petrovich could not afford to maintain such a beautiful kennel as his neighbor had. And somehow Dubrovsky enviously dropped: "... the kennel is wonderful, it is unlikely that your people live the same as your dogs." This phrase offended the kennel Troekurova. He replied that there were nobles who could envy the life of his master's dogs. Because of this, a serious quarrel arose. After that, the trial began. Because of this litigation, Andrei Gavrilovich became seriously ill. It was decided to inform his son Vladimir about this, who at that moment served in the guards regiment in St. Petersburg.
Vladimir can be called a spoiled young man, his father did not refuse him anything, he supplied him with all possible means as best he could. The young man was not accustomed to denying himself anything, he led a wild life, reveled and dreamed of a rich bride. His life flowed easily and cheerfully, until the news came of the poor health of his father and the deplorable state of the entire estate, which was about to pass into the hands of a neighbor. We must pay tribute to Vladimir, despite the fact that at first he resembles a simple rake, a reveler, in fact he turned out to be a kind, sympathetic person. He immediately leaves for his native Kistenevka.
When Vladimir arrived in Kistenevka, he saw that his father was getting worse and worse. After one of the meetings with Kirila Petrovich, Dubrovsky Sr. cannot stand it, he has a stroke and dies.
After this moment, Vladimir begins to consider Troekurov his natural enemy. Kirila Petrovich was not stopped by the death of his neighbor (and once a friend), and he continues the lawsuit. In addition, Troekurov treats the son of Dubrovsky Sr. badly. As a result, Kistenevka with all the people is given into the possession of Troekurov.
Dubrovsky spends his last evening at his former estate. He is very sad. He is sad and lonely from the death of a parent, from the loss of a family estate. The author often says that the young Dubrovsky lacked home warmth and comfort. On the last evening at home, he began to sort through his father's papers. So the letters of his late mother fell into his hands. Vladimir reads them, as if he plunges into that atmosphere of tenderness and warmth, which he has been missing for many years. He is so carried away by these letters, by his feelings, that he forgets about everything in the world.
Vladimir becomes unbearable the thought that the house of his ancestors can go to his enemy. He decides to burn down the house so that Troyekurov does not get anything. Vladimir is not an evil person, so he does not want victims. He wants to leave all the doors open so that people can escape from the burning building. But the serf Arkhip violates the will of the master, and the clerks burn in the fire.
As a result, Dubrovsky takes the faithful serfs and goes with them into the forest. It is important to note that the young man has a paternal attitude towards his people, he feels his responsibility for them.
Unable to find protection from the law, Dubrovsky becomes a cruel but noble robber. It is interesting that he never attacked the estate of his enemy Troekurov. Then it turns out that already at that time he was in love with his daughter Masha.
Despite the fact that Dubrovsky lived according to the cruel rules of force, he still remained just a “noble” robber. It can even be said that his moral character was much higher than that of those guardians of the law who allowed such injustice to happen as the transfer of property to someone else's possession.
As a result, feeling the inevitability of his sad fate, Vladimir dismisses the people loyal to him. He wants them to live a new life, more peaceful and righteous. The hero himself disappears.
It is a pity that the life of a kind, sympathetic, decent person turned out in this way. After all, now, in order to survive, he will have to hide all his life, most likely, he will never see his beloved girl again. I think that Dubrovsky's path is not the way out. He decided to administer justice on his own, without having any rights to do so. Robbery, no matter how noble it may look, is not a solution. It seems to me that Vladimir forgot about the Supreme Court, which really does not make mistakes, and which will reward everyone for their deeds.
Source: www.litra.ru
World literature is well aware of the image of a noble robber with a romantic soul. Most often, these were the nobles who experienced betrayal by close friends or felt the injustice of the law.
One of these knights, appearing under the cover of night, is the hero of Alexander Sergeevich Pushkin, Vladimir Dubrovsky. True, he did not immediately become a robber.
At the beginning of the work, we see Vladimir serving in the guards regiment after training in the Cadet Corps. He leads an easy life, not burdened by problems and worries - he plays cards, gets into debt, dreams of marrying a rich bride. Vladimir does not experience a shortage of funds at all, his father will send as much as necessary.
Only behind this outer shell is the soul, deprived of maternal affection and warm, confidential communication with the father. The young man respected and revered his parent, Andrei Gavrilovich Dubrovsky, with sadness and longing he recalled his native village and the houses where carefree childhood years had passed.
The elder Dubrovsky dies, unable to survive the loss of the family estate, which was taken away by a former friend and colleague of Kiril Petrovich Troekurov. Upon learning of what had happened, Vladimir burns down the estate, in which the life of a whole family of Dubrovskys passed, and, together with devoted servants, sets off to rob. It is easy to find an explanation for this seemingly monstrous act: under no circumstances should the memory of the closest people, letters of a beloved mother, be left to ridicule the enemy.
Vladimir Dubrovsky, who suddenly lost his father and home, understood what future lay ahead for him. Hopelessness and poverty are pushing him onto the wrong path, the path of robbery and robbery. A gang of people devoted to him burns rich estates, robs people on the roads, only Troekurov's estate is not attacked, because beloved Masha lives there. It was the feelings for this kind girl that extinguished the anger in Vladimir's soul, forced him to abandon his long-cherished revenge. It's just that it's impossible to end the robbery.
Attacks are on the rise. And although, continuing to show nobility, Vladimir does not take revenge on Troekurov, does not kill Prince Vereisky, who has become the unloved husband dear and sweet to Masha's heart, but he continues to follow this path, continues to hunt, and more and more boldly and cruelly.
But everything comes to an end. The nobility of the robber also ends. From the category of defender of the poor and innocent, he turns into a murderer. The death of an officer can no longer be justified. Vladimir understands this perfectly and dissolves the gang. Robberies and robberies stop. The epic of the noble avenger Dubrovsky is coming to an end.
Probably, one can find words, understand and explain the behavior of Vladimir Dubrovsky, analyze all the circumstances that pushed him to robbery. But the young man cannot be justified. He crossed the line between good and evil, he became a criminal. And this is a fact that cannot be canceled and forgotten.
Source: www.sochinyashka.ru
I consider Dubrovsky a victim, he is not a robber, because he only stole from the rich, he wanted to restore justice and prove to the rich that money is not the greatest value, that they do not give power. If you have power and great powers and opportunities, you need to remain human, treat people humanely, see them as equals, and not elevate yourself above them, and not allow yourself to treat a person as a thing, as Troekurov does. For his own amusement, he sent a living person to be torn to pieces by a ferocious animal and laughed at it. Dubrovsky would never do that.
From dinner at Troekurov's, we understand that he never robbed the poor and honest, one woman says that Dubrovsky wanted to steal money from the landowner, whom she sent to send money to her son. Having read the letter and found out that this was money for her son, he did not commit theft, but the landowner took the money and blamed Dubrovsky for everything, then he came to this lady, under the guise of a stranger and told the whole truth in order to restore justice. Vladimir stole money not for himself, but for his people, because he had no other choice. By his actions, he shows that he does not put up with fate and is not going to depend on Troekurov, his decision is correct for the current situation. If he gave everything to Troyekurov, it would be unfair to his people.
Dubrovsky had a hopeless situation, so he became a robber, but honest and fair. Vladimir takes the side of the people, he treats them as equals, does not look at them as servants, does not mock them, but only helps. He sees in a person, first of all, a person, and not a servant like Troekurov. He understood that Masha was the daughter of his enemy, but he did not regard her as such. He examined her inner world and realized that she is an honest and decent person, she is not at all like her father, Dubrovsky appreciates this. In a person, he appreciates positive qualities, he is not interested in material wealth, he himself is ready to give the last to the people.
Is it possible to justify the fact that Dubrovsky became a robber? This question was answered differently in our class. Some said that he had no other choice, that he had to take revenge on Troekurov for his ruin and the death of his father. Others did not understand his actions. Why become a robber? After all, it was possible to return to St. Petersburg and continue to serve. And in general, he is not the only person who was offended and ruined. Well, now everyone should go to the robbers?
Dubrovsky is very nice to me. And I want to try to understand it. Vladimir Dubrovsky grew up in a kind, good, honest family. His parents loved him very much, and he treated them with respect and love. They were poor nobles, but did not feel humiliated. Dubrovsky's father was a man of honor, with self-respect. And he raised his son that way.
Vladimir served in St. Petersburg. Suddenly he receives a letter from which he learns that the estate was taken from them by Troekurov and his father was dying. Dubrovsky arrives home and finds his father in a coffin. He lost the most dear, close person. And now he doesn't even have a home. The entire estate, by decision of an unfair court, belongs to Troekurov, the man who killed his father. And Dubrovsky turned out to be homeless and impoverished. The clerks, who came to take away the estate, treat it rudely, dismissively. Vladimir walks around his home for the last time. He cannot bear the thought that all this will go to his enemy. The portraits of his father and mother, dear to his heart, will be removed from the wall and thrown somewhere in a closet. He finds a bunch of his mother's letters, rereads them. How much care and motherly love they have! So do they also now belong to the one who took everything from him, ruined his father? Dubrovsky cannot accept this. He decides to set fire to the house. Let Troekurov not get it. Now he has no way back. After all, he is a criminal. In addition, the blacksmith Arkhip locked the door, and all the corrupt clerks in the house burned down. The serfs of Dubrovsky were very devoted to their masters. They were ready to rebel against Troekurov, recognizing only Dubrovsky as their master. Dubrovsky takes some of his people and goes into the forest. He becomes the leader of the robbers. But Dubrovsky is a noble robber. He never offended the poor, orphans, widows and robbed only the rich.
I am sorry that the fate of Dubrovsky was so sad. He lost his home, father, beloved girl, became an exile. I don't know if Dubrovsky can be justified in everything, but he can be understood.
DUBROVSKY (Novel, 1832-1833; publ. 1841) Dubrovsky Vladimir Andreevich - the protagonist of the unfinished novel, "the noble robber." D., which is rare in Pushkin's artistic system, has real prototypes. In 1832 in the Kozlovsky district ...
Chapter XII contains very important events: Dubrovsky reveals himself to Marya Kirilovna and leaves the Troyekurovs' house. He is being persecuted on the denunciation of Spitsyn. The students will find in the text the words of Dubrovsky, explaining to Masha the reason for his appearance in the Troyekurov house under the name ...
On the pages of "Dubrovsky" we get acquainted with many people of the nobility. Some of them are described fully and comprehensively (Troekurov, Dubrovskys), others are fragmentary (Prince Vereisky), others are mentioned in passing (Anna Savishna and other guests ...
I read the prose of the great Russian poet A.S. Pushkin "Dubrovsky". The main character in this work is the son of lieutenant Andrei Gavrilovich Dubrovsky - Vladimir Andreevich Dubrovsky, who was left without an inheritance due to a quarrel between ...
The image of another local nobleman, Andrei Gavrilovich Dubrovsky, appears before us in a completely different way. “Being peers, born in the same class, brought up in the same way ...”, having similar characters and inclinations, Troekurov and Dubrovsky Sr. in different ways ...
