In what situations can a Solomon decision be made? "Solomon's solution"

28.03.2019

Events on the rebellious peninsula, whose people sincerely, with love and hope turned their gaze towards Russia, stirred up Ukrainian “patriotic feelings” like a storm. Some should be reminded that a patriot is a person who loves his homeland and is ready to make sacrifices and deeds for it. The patriot carefully preserves his homeland: “Like a bride, we love the Motherland, we take care of it like an affectionate mother!”

But patriotism in the “Ukrainian” version went off scale:
“Crimea will be Ukrainian or deserted,” said Kiev TV presenter Danilo Yanevsky on Public Television.
“Either Crimea will be an autonomy within Ukraine, or it will be a scorched and impoverished territory for a long time,” MP Inna Bogoslovskaya confirms her tender love for Ukraine and its people.

Are the “patriots” threatening to turn Crimea into a scorched desert?!... The decoration, the joy, the fairy tale of our lives is Crimea. A piece of heaven on earth. “And if we really want happiness, you and I will go to Crimea,” the poet wrote silver age Ilya Selvinsky. Maximilian Voloshin is buried in Koktebel...

Understand the simple lesson of my land:
How Greece and Genoa passed,
So blowjob everything - Europe and Russia.
Civil unrest is a combustible element
Will dispel... Will usher in a new century
In the backwaters of everyday life there are other places...
Days fade, people pass by.

But heaven and earth are the same from eternity.
Therefore, live for the current day.
Bless your blue eye.
Be as simple as the wind, inexhaustible as the sea,
And full of memory, like the earth.
Love the distant sail of a ship
And the song of the waves rustling in the open space.
All the thrill of life of all ages and races
Lives in you. Always. Now. Now.
December 25, 1926

And they threaten to take THIS away from their “beloved people”?!
In my opinion, such statements (“Don’t let anyone get you!” A.N. Ostrovsky, “Dowry”) say no less about the new government than the law banning the Russian language, which, by the way, was urgently repealed: it’s not time yet for now, then, when the turmoil passes and everything is “stable”, then “we will settle scores with them later!” (May Bulat Shalvovich forgive me for using the lines from his poem “Oh, war, what have you done, vile ..." in such a context).

Let's turn to biblical wisdom - let's resort to Solomon's solution (the meaning of the phraseological unit " Solomon's solution" - this is a wise and simple solution to an intractable issue, named after the ancient Hebrew wise king Solomon).
Let me remind you of the parable:

One day, two women came to King Solomon, known for his wisdom. They lived in the same house and were neighbors. Both recently gave birth to a child.

Last night, one of them accidentally crushed her baby in her sleep and placed the dead child with another woman, and took the living one from her. In the morning, the women began to argue, each arguing that the living child was hers, and the dead one was the neighbor’s.

They argued the same way before the king. After listening to them, Solomon ordered to bring a sword.
The sword was immediately brought. Without a moment's hesitation, King Solomon said:

Let both be happy. Cut the living child in half and give each half of the baby.
One of the women, hearing his words, changed her face and prayed:
- Give the child to my neighbor, she is his mother, just don’t kill him!
The other, on the contrary, agreed with the king’s decision.
“Chop it, don’t let it get to her or me,” she said decisively.

Then King Solomon said:
- Do not kill the child, but give him to the first woman: she is his real mother.
*

So who is the real mother for Crimea: Ukraine or Russia?
Here are some opinions from the Internet (profanity removed):
- Here it is, hypocrisy in pure form. And after this they tell us that no one will oppress Sevastopol and Crimea.
"This land has belonged from time immemorial Crimean Tatars... This land is, was and will be Ukrainian territory,” the TV presenter added. -Did they rewrite this part of history too?
- And Admiral Ushakov is the founder of the tactics of the Ukrainian Cossacks at sea.)))
- No matter how hard the wolf tries to dress up in sheep's clothing, his true intentions still slip through...
- Kyiv became a fascist city - that’s a fact. I’m wondering: will Kyiv veterans be able to go to the parade on May 9?! Or we will see a Nazi parade in Kyiv.

I found the following information on the Internet:

The expression “Solomon's solution” came to us from ancient legends. The Jewish king Solomon, son of David, was known as a great sage. Many legends have been written about his cunning, but most of them describe his wisdom and ingenuity in resolving disputes and judicial matters.

One day two women came to Solomon and were arguing about whose child it was. Solomon decided to cut the child in half and give half to each woman. The woman who was a deceiver easily agreed to this decision. And the mother, horrified, said: “Better give my rival the child alive.” Thus, the real mother was found.

This is where it came from that “Solomon’s court” is the fairest and wisest, “Solomon’s decision” is original, witty, finding a way out of any delicate situation.

In connection with this story, I want to raise several questions for discussion:

    Did the king decide to cut the child in half and give half to each woman? So? Both women took his decision not as a joke, but as a royal decision, because the king had even already ordered a sword to be brought to him. So why was his “royal decision” not carried out? Did King Shlomo really want to cut the child in half? I think the king was wise enough not to want this. And if so, then we are not dealing with a “royal decision,” but with a well-thought-out provocation for a obviously expected reaction. So we come to the conclusion that the so-called “Solomon decision” is not essentially a judicial decision, but is simply a judicial “provocative trick” to expose deception. So?

    What's the point of a liar taking on the burden of caring for someone else's child? If she just wanted to satisfy the instinct of motherhood after losing her own child, she could only take on the role of nurse of another child (after all, both women lived in the same house). After all, being a mother is a big responsibility. There must be some pretty compelling reasons for taking on this responsibility. But, on the other hand, this same deceiver agreed with the “king’s decision” to kill the child. How can this happen at the same time?

About these two questions, about a year ago I listened to a lecture by a rabbi from Israel who came to Germany. Are you interested in knowing the answers to these questions? Want to know what he said?

For reference, I quote an excerpt from the Russian translation (Old Testament):

Two women came to the king and stood before him. And one woman said:

Oh my lord! This woman and I live in the same house. And I gave birth in her presence in this house. On the third day after I gave birth, this woman gave birth too. And we were together, and there was no one else in the house with us; only the two of us were in the house. And the woman's son died at night, because she slept with him. And she arose at night and took my son from me while I, your servant, was sleeping, and laid him to her breast, and she laid her dead son to my breast. In the morning I got up to feed my son, and behold, he was dead. And when I looked at him in the morning, it was not my son whom I gave birth to.

And the other woman said:

- No, my son is alive, and your son is dead.

And she told her:

- No, your son is dead, but mine is alive.

And they said this before the king.

And the king said:

This one says: “My son is alive, but your son is dead”; and she says: “No, your son is dead, but my son is alive.” - And the king said, “Give me the sword.”

And they brought the sword to the king. And the king said:

- Cut the living child in two and give half to one and half to the other.

And the woman whose son was alive answered the king, for her whole insides were agitated with pity for her son:

- Oh, my lord! Give her this child alive and do not kill him.

And the other one said:

- Let it be neither for me nor for you, chop it down.

And the king answered and said:

- Give this living child and do not kill him. She is his mother.

And all Israel heard of the judgment, as the king judged; and they began to fear the king, for they saw that the wisdom of God was in him to carry out judgment.

(1 Kings 3:16-28)

Solomon (Heb. שְׁלֹמֹה , Shlomo; Greek Σαλωμών, Σολωμών in the Septuagint; lat. Solomon in the Vulgate; Arab. سليمان‎‎ Suleiman in the Koran) - the third Jewish king, the legendary ruler of the united Kingdom of Israel in 965-928 BC. e., during its peak period. Son of King David and Bathsheba (Bat Sheba), his co-ruler in 967-965 BC. e. During the reign of Solomon, the Jerusalem Temple, the main shrine of Judaism, was built in Jerusalem.

Nikolay Ge. The Court of King Solomon.
1854.

Solomon's decision is what we call a fair, wise and speedy judgment.

The Bible tells us about King Solomon. He was the son of the famous King David and ruled the Kingdom of Judah in the 10th century BC. It was Solomon who built the first Temple in Jerusalem. But this king became especially famous for his wisdom.

One day in a dream, Solomon heard the voice of God, who told him: “Ask what to give you.” The king asked for wisdom to rule his people fairly. And because Solomon did not ask for any personal benefits, such as longevity or wealth, God fulfilled his request, making Solomon the wisest of kings.

One day they brought two women with a baby to Solomon for trial. They lived in the same house and gave birth to sons three days apart. But one of them had a child die at night. The first woman claimed that her neighbor switched children, taking her living child for herself. The second woman claimed that she did nothing of the sort, and that night the first woman’s child died. How was it possible to figure out in this situation which of the two women was telling the truth and was the real mother of the child? Without witnesses, it was impossible to establish the truth, and genetic analysis did not exist at that time. Then King Solomon ordered to bring a sword and divide the child between two women, cutting him in half. Hearing about this decision, the first woman screamed that the child should not be killed, but given to her neighbor. The second one was satisfied with this decision. “Let it be neither for me nor for you,” she said.

Then everyone realized who the real mother of the child was. By order of the king, the son was returned to the woman who asked to leave him alive. This biblical story many were impressed by its non-standard and subtle solution controversial issue. Hence the expression "Solomon's court" firmly entrenched in our speech.

God heard Solomon's prayers and gave him great wisdom. Solomon collected three thousand into one book wise parables and composed a thousand songs. He knew everything about animals, birds and fish, herbs and flowers. The fame of his wisdom spread throughout the entire earth. With God's help, Solomon also became a skillful and fair judge.

Subjects came to the king to seek from him righteous judgment and asked to listen to them - just as before they came to David.

One day two women came to the palace. The guards led them to the royal throne. As they approached, one woman tried to snatch the package that the other was holding in her hands, but suddenly the package squeaked and began to cry. It was a baby!

One of the guards took the child in his arms and began to rock him, and the women began vying with each other to complain to the king.

“We live in the same house,” said the first. “I recently gave birth, and on the third day after I gave birth, this woman gave birth too. At night she accidentally crushed her child and he died. While I was sleeping, she took my child and carried him to her bed, and laid him dead next to me. In the morning I got up and saw that my son was dead; and when I looked closely, it was not mine, but her baby!

Another woman angrily interrupted the speaker:

No, this is my son alive, and yours is dead!

So they argued, standing in front of the king, until he finally asked:

So, do you both consider this baby yours?

Yes! - the women exclaimed.

Give me the sword,” Solomon ordered.

When a guard appeared with a sword, the king said to him:

If each woman claims that the child is hers, cut the child in two and give half to one and half to the other.

As soon as Solomon spoke these words, the woman who was the real mother of the baby screamed:

Don't kill him! Give her this child, just don't kill him!

And the other one said:

Let neither me nor you get it. Chop!

Before understanding and defining the meaning and meaning of the expression “Judgment of Solomon,” let us plunge into the very ancient history and let us turn to the Bible for help to find out who Solomon was and why he became so famous. And here it should immediately be noted that the name Solomon (Shlomo) is translated from Hebrew as “peacemaker.”

Just one statement about Solomon and his court is worth a lot and it goes like this: “The main thing is wisdom, acquire wisdom and with all your possessions acquire understanding. Appreciate it and it will exalt you.”

King Solomon

Solomon was third king of the Jews, whose reign dates from approximately 967-928 BC. He was also the son of Bathsheba. Even at birth, the prophet Nathan singled him out from all the sons of David, who later became the most intelligent and dispassionate ruler. It was he who built the First on He had a talent for foresight and was very sensitive, so many legends and fairy tales are associated with his name.

Solomon's judgment was always fair and wise. There is a legend that when God appeared to him in a dream and promised to fulfill his every desire, Solomon asked for a reasonable heart in order to correctly judge his people and be able to distinguish between good and evil. Solomon became a peaceful king; during the forty years of his reign there was not a single great war. He was an excellent diplomat, merchant and builder, and under him chariots, cavalry and a merchant fleet appeared in the Jewish army. He strengthened and rebuilt his Jerusalem, which began to drown in luxury and wealth. King Solomon made silver equal to simple stones.

The price of disobedience

But, like any king, he also made mistakes, and therefore after his death his state fell apart. One of the reasons was the king’s construction of temples and pagan idols for his many wives, who were often from different races and religions. He even swore an oath to participate personally in some pagan cults.

The oral Torah Midrash describes that when King Solomon married his daughter Egyptian pharaoh, then the Archangel Gabriel descended from heaven to earth and stuck his pole into the depths of the sea, on this place Rome was subsequently built, which would later conquer Jerusalem.

The biblical “Book of Kingdoms” says that at the end of his life God again appeared before Solomon and told him that he would tear his kingdom away from him, since he had not fulfilled His covenants and statutes, but during his lifetime he would not do this because of his father. David. After the death of Solomon, his once strong and powerful kingdom fell apart into two weak states of Israel and Judah, which began to fight among themselves.

Solomon's Judgment: Meaning

There is such a popular expression among the people - “Solomon’s court” or “Solomon’s decision”. It implies a quick, witty and at the same time unexpected solution, which helps to deftly get out of some difficult and very controversial situation. This phraseological unit “Judgment of Solomon” is used in the meaning of “quick and wise.”

Examples of Solomon's wise decisions

One day Solomon began to judge two women who could not share a baby between them. They lived in the same house, and almost at the same time they each had a baby. At night, one of the women slept with her child, and he died. Then she took the living child from another and transferred her dead one to her. The next morning a fierce argument arose between the women. So they came to Solomon for judgment. He, having listened to their story, ordered to cut the child in half and distribute the halves to the mothers. One of the women immediately decided: it would be better if no one got it. Another begged not to kill the baby, and immediately allowed another woman to take the child, as long as he remained alive. Having defined in it real mother, King Solomon immediately ordered the child to be given to this woman.

Pharaoh's Help

One day Solomon took the daughter of Pharaoh as his wife when he was building the Holy of Holies - the temple of his Lord, and one day he decided to send an ambassador to his father-in-law with a request to help him. Pharaoh immediately sent six hundred people who were destined for death according to the horoscope to help Solomon. Thus, he wanted to test the wisdom of the king of Israel. Solomon, seeing them from afar, ordered shrouds to be sewn for them, and then assigned his ambassador to them and told his father-in-law that if he had nothing to bury his dead in, then here are the clothes for them and let him bury them at home.

Solomon's trial of the three brothers

The dying father called his three sons to give his last orders regarding the inheritance. They came to him, and he told them that he had a treasure buried somewhere in the ground, there were three vessels there, standing friend on a friend. Let the eldest go to the top vessel, the middle one to the next, and the youngest to the bottom. When the father died, they dug up the treasure and saw that the first vessel was filled with gold, the second with bones, and the third with earth. The brothers, in horror, began to argue over the gold and could not divide it. It was then that they decided to come to Solomon so that he would justly resolve them

Solomon's court, as always, was very wise; he ordered the gold to be given to the elder brother, livestock and servants to the middle one, and vineyards, grain and fields to the younger one. And told them that their father was smart person, since he so competently divided everything between them during his lifetime.



Similar articles